How credit reports are put together

The three nationwide credit bureaus are Equifax, Experian and TransUnion. They don't create your account information themselves. Instead, they compile reports from information supplied by furnishers: lenders, card issuers and collection agencies. Each bureau keeps its own file, which is why your three reports can look a little different.

So an error can start in two places. A furnisher can send the wrong information, or a bureau can handle correct information in the wrong way. Knowing which is more likely helps you send your dispute to the right place.

Errors that usually start with the creditor (furnisher)

These errors usually begin with the information a lender, card issuer or collector sends to the bureaus:

  • Wrong balance: the amount reported doesn't match your statement.
  • Late payment reported in error: a payment marked late when it was on time.
  • Wrong account status: for example, an account shown as open when you closed it.
  • Paid debt shown as unpaid: a debt you paid still reported with a balance.

Because the furnisher sends the same information to each bureau it reports to, a furnisher-side error often shows up on more than one report.

Errors that usually start with the credit bureau

These errors often come from how a bureau compiles or maintains your file:

  • Mixed files: information from someone with a similar name or Social Security number appears on your report.
  • Duplicate accounts: the same account listed more than once.
  • Outdated items: negative information still reported after its reporting period.
  • Wrong personal information: an incorrect name, address or other identifying detail.

A bureau-side error may appear on only one of your three reports, since each bureau keeps its own file.

If the same mistake appears on all three reports, it may have started with the furnisher. If it appears on only one, it may have started with that bureau. That's a clue, not a rule, so dispute wherever the error shows up.

Who to contact: a simple table

Type of errorLikely sourceWho to dispute with
Wrong balanceFurnisherThe bureau and the furnisher
Late payment reported in errorFurnisherThe bureau and the furnisher
Wrong account statusFurnisherThe bureau and the furnisher
Paid debt shown as unpaidFurnisherThe bureau and the furnisher
Mixed fileBureauThe bureau
Duplicate accountBureauThe bureau
Outdated itemBureauThe bureau
Wrong personal informationBureauThe bureau

Not sure? Dispute with the bureau that shows the error. It forwards your dispute to the company that supplied the information.

What the law requires of each

Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), both credit bureaus and furnishers must investigate disputes. When you dispute with a bureau, it forwards your dispute to the company that supplied the information. You can also dispute directly with the furnisher in writing, at the dispute address it lists.

The practical approach: dispute with the bureau, and when the error started with the lender or collector, dispute with the furnisher too. Our guide on how to dispute a credit report error, step by step covers what to include and the timelines to expect.

If a deleted item comes back

Sometimes an item that was deleted is put back on your report later. This is called reinsertion. If it happens, the furnisher must certify that the information is accurate, and the bureau must notify you in writing within 5 business days. If you still believe the item is wrong, you can dispute it again and file a complaint at consumerfinance.gov/complaint.

When an error might be identity theft

Accounts, inquiries or addresses you don't recognize at all may be a mixed file, or they may be a sign of identity theft. If you suspect identity theft, visit IdentityTheft.gov for a personalized recovery plan.

Tips for keeping track

  • Note which reports show each error. It's a clue to where it started.
  • Keep copies of every dispute and every response.
  • Check all three reports again after a dispute is resolved.
  • If an account seems to be missing rather than wrong, see accounts missing from your credit report.
  • For a broader list of mistakes to look for, see common credit report errors.

If you'd like help sorting it out

You can handle disputes on your own, for free. If your reports have several issues and you'd like help finding and documenting them first, a credit report audit gives you a written review that notes where each possible issue appears.

Where to go next

Because each bureau keeps its own file, an error may appear on only one report. A three-bureau credit report audit compares all three, and our dispute coordination service can help you track each bureau's response.